The BEST Stuffed Peppers Recipe Ever (Made Easy With Rice & Ground Beef)

These scrumptious, husky stuffed peppers are simply one of a kind! If you’ve been craving stuffed peppers or looking for a delicious recipe, your search stops right here.

Why? Because stuffed peppers can’t get any better than this. They’re guaranteed crowd-pleasers, making them the ultimate choice for social gatherings, game days, and family dinners.

I must say, this is a recipe I’m very proud of because it’s not only one of my fan favorites, but I created it years ago at 27, knowing very little about stuffed peppers.

Outside of knowing you have to pre-boil them and stuff them with rice and meat, I had no idea what I was doing. I just used my God-given creativity to pull it off.

Most of my dishes were inspired by the usual suspects, lol: Nana Alice, Grandma Gwen, or a restaurant dish I tried to mimic.

But this fat husky mofo of a stuffed pepper recipe right here? That was all me! So I’m super excited to share it with y’all and see what y’all think.

Watch Me Make It

My Childhood Love/Hate Relationship with Bell Peppers

I didn’t care much for bell peppers as a kid—mostly because they always looked weird and ugly to me. I mean, we can agree bell peppers are funny-looking, right?

They’re practically the one vegetable people use to insult someone’s physique because of how strangely shaped they are. Lmbo!

Growing up in Philly, we’d bust on each other all the time as kids. It was a core part of our culture. We’d call it “busting,” “roasting,” or “clowning” someone in school, and bell peppers were a regular go-to target for roasting people because of those weird shapes. Lol!

Between using them as an insult to roast people and finding them straight-up bizarre, I had way more negative thoughts about bell peppers than positive ones.

I wasn’t too fond of how they tasted, or of their funky forest-green color! Lol! Once I got older and realized they came in other beautiful shades of red, orange, and yellow, I started seeing them in a better light. LMBO!

I always saw four or five of them sitting in the bottom drawer of my grandma’s refrigerator. One thing my grandmother made sure she kept in stock was a bunch of fat, husky bell peppers.

I still have vivid images of her slicing and dicing them on her cutting board with a big chef’s knife right alongside eye-torching onions.

As a young’un, I was always up under my grandma Viola, Gwen, and Nana. Every time they cooked something, I would pull a chair up and sit in the kitchen like I was in class. Watching them cook was so entertaining to me.

I guess that was an early sign that I would grow up to become a cook. Since they put peppers in everything—from potato salad to baked turkey wings and collard greens—I figured out real quick they made food taste better.

Over time, my taste buds finally evolved to love them.

The First Time I Tried Stuffed Peppers

The first time I ever tried a stuffed bell pepper was at a social gathering my mom went to. I really loved the filling, but I didn’t eat the bell pepper itself because it wasn’t tender.

Even back then, though, I knew I would make them for myself one day and get them right. I never thought I’d grow up to create a recipe and share it with the world!

It’s funny because my mom just did the same thing the other day after I finished making this recipe! Lol! She ate the meat and rice and threw away most of the pepper. It’s like, why even stuff the peppers if you aren’t gonna eat them?

Now, in her defense, she can’t have too much acid, but when a pepper is cooked right and eaten together with the filling, that’s what makes the whole dish work.

Bell peppers don’t get any respect. Lol! Well, they have my respect now because they elevate so many of my dishes.

Enough yapping, folks. Listen, I originally uploaded a video tutorial for these back in 2014, and I’m glad I finally created an actual recipe for y’all now.

Let’s get into it!

Ingredients you’ll need:

Here are all the ingredients you’ll need for this delicious dish.

Meat & Rice Filling

• Meat: You’re gonna use equal parts ground beef and sweet Italian sausage. Use 80/20 ground beef for moisture and flavor. If you don’t eat pork, you can replace the sweet Italian sausage with more ground beef, ground turkey, or chicken. I would recommend turkey.
• Vegetables: We’ll be using standard yellow onions and stewed tomatoes.
• Rice: I keep it simple and use 1 family-size bag of 10-minute Success white rice, which totals 3 cups of cooked rice. I use the 10-minute Success white rice because it cooks quickly.
• Liquid: 2 Quarts of cool water is enough to cover 1 family-size bag of rice.
• Cheese: We’re gonna use Parmesan cheese. Make sure you pick up a block of Parmesan cheese and grate it yourself.
• Condiments: I added ketchup not only to give the filling a saucy tomato flavor but to add a hint of sweetness to a dish that has a decent amount of acidity. Tomato paste thickens the filling and gives it a nice reddish color and a rich tomato flavor. Worcestershire sauce adds depth of flavor and gives the filling a mild smoky flavor. Garlic paste brings that punchy savory kick. I always use Worcestershire sauce when I’m creating a recipe that calls for ground beef.
• Seasonings: I like to use celery salt for taste because it adds depth of flavor; Italian seasonings and Oregano for herbs; red pepper flakes for heat; black pepper and brown sugar to neutralize all the acidity.

Bell Peppers

• Peppers: 6 green bell peppers. Go for big bell peppers! The taller, the better, so there’s no filling left over.
• Water: Use 3 qts of water to preboil the peppers. We’re using a good amount of water to fill and cover the peppers so they’re fully submerged.

Bed

• Liquid: To keep the peppers from sticking, we’ll be adding 1 cup of stewed tomato Juice to the baking dish.
• Vegetables: We’ll be adding a small amount of yellow onions to the baking dish.

Topping

• Vegetables: We’re going to add stewed tomatoes to the top of our stuffed peppers.
• Cheese: We’re going to add more shredded Parmesan and sharp yellow cheddar to the top for flavor and color.
• Seasonings: Parsley flakes are a garnish I like to sprinkle over the cheese for aesthetic purposes. It makes the peppers more appetizing; I don’t always use it, though.

Shopping Guide

Nothing is more frustrating than getting halfway through prepping a recipe only to realize you didn’t buy quite enough of a key ingredient.

Or what about when you’re standing in the grocery aisle trying to decode whether a standard can size will actually cover what the recipe calls for?

When you’re dealing with specific quantities like exact cups of tomatoes or matching cheese ratios, eyeballing it at the store is a gamble you shouldn’t have to take.

To take all the guesswork out of your trip to the market, I’ve put together this quick shopping breakdown. It covers the exact package sizes and minimum amounts you’ll need to grab.

This way, you’ll have plenty of ingredients on hand for both the filling and the delicious cheesy topping so that you won’t come up short.

• Stewed tomatoes: Since we’re using a total of 2 cups of stewed tomatoes and 2 cups of stewed tomato juice, you will need either 1 (30 oz) can of stewed tomatoes or 2 (14oz) cans of stewed tomatoes.
• Block Parmesan & Cheddar Cheese: We’re using 1-1/2 cups of shredded Parmesan cheese and 1/2 cup of block sharp yellow cheddar. So you’ll need to buy 1 (8oz) block of Parmesan cheese and 1 (8 oz) block of sharp yellow cheddar cheese.

Prepping and Parboiling the Peppers

First things first, we have to prep and parboil our bell peppers. Don’t skip this step—pre-boiling is the secret to keeping the peppers tender and juicy when you bite into them!

These are the step-by-step prepping instructions for our bell peppers.

1. Cut off the top crown. Cut a nice big circle off the top of the pepper, removing the stem and the surrounding top shoulders. Don’t cut too far down the sides, though—you still want the peppers to stay tall enough to hold a ton of the delicious filling, lol!
2. Trim the rim. Take your knife and slide it around the top edges to clean it up and create a nice, flat surface so the rim is even all the way around.
3. Clear out the membranes. Carefully cut and clean out all the white membranes and seeds inside. Remove as much as you can, but be careful not to poke any holes in the bottom or sides. We don’t want our filling oozing out everywhere.
4. Parboil them. Drop your cored peppers into a pot of scorching-hot water, making sure the water covers them completely so they soften evenly. This shortens your baking time later.
5. Don’t overcook them. It doesn’t take long for them to soften up in that hot water. You want them to have some structural bite so they can hold their shape—not super mushy or falling apart. 10 minutes will do the job.

Follow Me On Pinterest

Step-by-step instructions

1. Place a medium pot over high heat.
2. Add 2 quarts of water.
3. Once the water comes to a boil, add the rice and boil for 10 minutes.
4. Meanwhile, place a large skillet over medium heat.
5. Add the ground beef and sweet Italian sausage.
6. Break up the meat with a spatula and cook for 10 minutes, or until browned.
7. Drain the fat.
8. Add 1 cup of the chopped onions, celery salt, Italian seasoning, oregano, and black pepper, and continue cooking for 5 more minutes.
9. Once done, add the garlic paste and stir well.
10. Add the meat and rice to a large mixing bowl.
11. Add 1 cup of the shredded Parmesan cheese, tomato paste, ketchup, brown sugar, Worcestershire, and red pepper flakes.
12. Stir until well combined and set aside.
13. Place a large pot over high heat.
14. Add 3 quarts of water.
15. Gut out the peppers.
16. Once the water comes to a boil, add the peppers and boil for 10 minutes (3 at a time).
17. Preheat oven to 350°F.
18. Meanwhile, add 1/4 cup of onions and 1 cup of stewed tomato juice to the baking dish.
19. Once the peppers are done, place them in the baking dish.
20. Stuff the peppers with the filling.
21. Spoon 1 cup of stewed tomatoes and 1 cup of stewed tomato juice over the peppers.
22. Bake the peppers for 30 minutes.
23. Top the peppers with 1/2 cup of shredded Parmesan cheese, 1/2 cup of Cheddar cheese, and parsley flakes.
24. Bake the peppers for 10 more minutes.

Tips for best results:

• Use big peppers: The bigger and wider, the better! This way, they hold plenty of filling, and you don’t end up with a bunch of leftover meat and rice.
• Taste test: Give the filling a taste test before stuffing the peppers and baking them. This is the best time to decide if the filling needs more of anything.
• Stir well: Make sure that, when creating the filling, everything is fully incorporated, including the paste, to ensure the filling is well-balanced in taste. Also, break those stewed tomatoes up while stirring if they’re too big and chunky.
• Watch your cheese levels: Keep a balanced amount of cheese on top rather than piling on a massive, heavy layer—too much dry cheese without enough juice will seize up and dry out in the oven.

Variations for Stuffed Bell Peppers:

• Ground turkey: Got some ground turkey on hand? It won’t taste the same, but it’s still delicious. If you want a leaner, healthier option, go with ground turkey.

• Ground chicken: Ground or shredded chicken is another solid option. It will taste different, which is to be expected, but it will be just as good. This is a great alternative if you don’t eat red meat or pork.

• Different rice: You can get fancy and switch to yellow or brown rice if you like. Use whatever type of rice you think pairs well with the other ingredients.
• Mozzarella cheese: Want to switch it up? Try mozzarella. It’s a fantastic alternative that stretches and melts down smoothly every time.

Storage and reheating

• How do you store stuffed peppers? Cover them with plastic wrap or aluminum foil, or keep them tightly sealed in a Tupperware bowl, then store in the refrigerator.
• Can you freeze stuffed peppers? Yes, you can! Let them cool completely, wrap them individually with plastic wrap, then with aluminum foil, or store them in a heavy-duty freezer container. They’ll last for up to 2 to 3 months. Just thaw them out in the fridge before reheating.
• How to reheat stuffed peppers in the oven? I reheat them in the oven at 350°F. I split them open and bake them on a baking sheet or aluminum foil until they’re nice and warm throughout, about 20 minutes.
• How to reheat stuffed peppers in a microwave? Place a pepper on a microwave-safe plate, cover it loosely with a paper towel, and microwave in 1-minute intervals until heated all the way through. It’s quick, but the oven will give you a better texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Can you use peppers of different colors, and what’s the difference between them? Green is the least ripe and the most bitter, so it’s not as sweet as the others—red peppers are the sweetest. So yes, you can use peppers in different colors, but definitely use green.
• Do I have to parboil the peppers? Yes, boiling them for about 10 minutes beforehand softens them, removes bitterness, and reduces the final oven baking time.
• What’s a bed? Just a pile or layer of food that food is placed over. I use stewed tomato juice and onions to create a bed for the stuffed peppers, to prevent them from sticking.
• Do you cover them while baking? No! The peppers will get fork-tender by just baking them. Doesn’t require aluminum foil because they’re already done for the most part because we parboil them first.
• How long do stuffed peppers last? They taste best, in my experience, when eaten within 3 to 4 days, tops.

Other ground beef and sausage recipes

• Easy Dirty Rice Recipe 
• Easy Spaghetti And Meat Sauce Recipe 
• World’s Best Classic Shepherd’s Pie Recipe

Cookware and utensils you’ll need:

• Large pot: Use at least a 10-quart pot so it’s large enough to boil several peppers at once and hold plenty of water. You’ll need a smaller pot to boil the rice.
• Large skillet: You need a large skillet to brown the meat.
• Cheese grater: You’ll need this to shred the cheese.
• Big spoon: Use a large spoon to stir the filling.
• Large mixing bowl: Make sure you have a large mixing bowl to create the filling.
• Sharp knife: You need a knife to slice the pepper head open and remove all the glands inside.
• Casserole dish: At least an 8×10 baking dish to hold six bell peppers.

Ok, so that’s it, folks. Give this recipe a shot, leave a comment below letting me know how ya like it, and please don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more bangin’ recipes.

Enjoy, later!

PBJ~

Print